Restaurant Recommendations: My Cape Cod Favorites

Restaurant Recommendations: My Cape Cod Favorites

Cape Cod Restaurant Recommendations (My Personal Favorites)

One of my favorite things to do on Cape Cod is try new restaurants—and I take my recommendations very seriously. So here it is: my growing list of Cape Cod spots I genuinely love (and fully intend to keep adding to… once I work up another appetite).

The best part about Cape Cod is that it’s powered by small businesses. That means what you’re eating is often coming from family recipes, local fishermen and farmers, and people who truly care about the food they’re serving. There’s a real sense of pride and care in every meal.

From casual beachside lobster rolls to romantic dinners and hidden gems, these are my favorite Cape Cod restaurants.

Elevated Dining + Special Nights Out

  • Nor’east Beer Garden (Provincetown) — Incredible cocktails, great food, and a rotating seasonal menu ($$)

  • Leonessa (Yarmouth) — Beautiful cocktails, excellent food, and a refined rotating menu ($$$)

  • The Pheasant (Dennis) — One of my favorite atmospheres on the Cape with consistently great food ($$$)

  • Bailene (Dennis) — Wine bar with small plates, great atmosphere and thoughtful menu ($$)

  • Ciro & Sal’s (Provincetown) — Romantic Italian restaurant, perfect for a special night out ($$–$$$)

  • Case del Cabo (Eastham) — Something a little different from classic Cape Cod fare, always interesting and well done ($$)

  • Sal’s Place (Provincetown) — Super unique waterfront vibe, cash-only, incredible food, and amazing service ($$)

 

  • Mac’s Shack (Wellfleet) — A must-visit for oysters, cocktails, and a fun, lively atmosphere ($$)

  • The Beachcomber (Wellfleet) — A Cape Cod staple. Classic beach bar food, raw bar, and an unbeatable dune-top atmosphere ($$)

  • Lobster Pot (Provincetown) — A Provincetown institution with consistent food, history, and classic Cape Cod hospitality ($$)

  • Navillus (Orleans) — Great atmosphere with standout dishes like fish tacos and tuna nachos ($$)

Sandwiches, Deli Stops & Casual Lunch

  • Ack Goia (Brewster) — Incredible sandwiches with homemade focaccia and fresh mozzarella

  • Sam’s Deli — I recommend sandwiches on focaccia—worth every bite and huge

  • Scribiano’s (Harwich) — Classic deli with consistently great options

  • Cottage Street Bakery (Orleans) — Homemade bread and baked goods in an adorable bakery setting

  • Ocean Street Diner (Hyannis) — Classic diner stop with solid comfort food

  • The Knack (Orleans + Hyannis) — Great burgers and chicken fingers, perfect casual stop

  • The Canteen (Provincetown) - my go to recommendation for lunch in Provincetown because of it's causal waterfront dining and refreshing take on Cape Cod cuisine

Seafood Takeout + Classic Cape Stops

  • Sesuit Harbor Café (Dennis) — One of the best lobster rolls on Cape Cod, BYOB, cash-only, unbeatable harbor views

  • Chatham Fish Pier (Chatham) — Fresh lobster rolls, working fishing pier, and amazing seal watching

  • Sir Cricket’s (Orleans) — The best fish and chips for a quick takeout stop

  • PJ’s (Wellfleet) — Classic casual seafood spot

  • Arnold’s (Eastham) — Famous for fried seafood, onion rings, ice cream, and mini golf all in one stop

Breakfast + Coffee Favorites

  • Hangar B (Chatham) — One of the best breakfast spots on Cape Cod, located at a small airport

  • The Rail (Orleans) — Great breakfast with outdoor seating

  • Hole in One (Orleans + Eastham) — Famous Cape Cod donuts

  • Cottage Street Bakery (Orleans) — Homemade bread and croissants for breakfast sandwiches, baked goods, and coffee in an adorable bakery setting

  • Viv's Kitchen (Orleans) - Fresh and healthy options like smoothie bowls, with a refreshing Brazlian influence

 

  • Homeport (Orleans) — Cozy, classic diner-style breakfast

  • Liz’s Café (Provincetown) — Charming breakfast and brunch spot

  • Sesuit Harbor Café (Dennis) — Also great for an early lunch or brunch with a view

  • Pain D’Avignon (Hyannis / Chatham area) — Excellent bakery and brunch options

Honorable Mentions + Fun Finds

  • The Bowling Alley (Provincetown) — BBQ and fun casual atmosphere

  • Barley Neck Inn (Orleans) — Casual outdoor dining in summer, always good food

  • Rosie’s (Provincetown) — Quick, authentic Mexican food

 

Back to blog